Compare
The table below sets every body against every question. For two bodies at a time, a pair page puts each one's own sourced account beneath the answer — which is where the real distance shows.
Pairs worth reading together
Any two bodies can be compared, and there is a page for every combination. These are the ones that carry an argument: three where one body was formed by congregations leaving the other, and three where a shared tradition turns out to settle less than a reader would expect.
-
The Presbyterian pair
PCUSA · PCA — one formed from the other
-
The Methodist pair
UMC · GMC — one formed from the other
-
The Anglican pair
TEC · ACNA — one formed from the other
-
The Lutheran pair
ELCA · LCMS — same tradition, neither descended from the other
-
Two structures within one Church
RC (dioceses) · RC (institutes) — same tradition, neither descended from the other
-
Two religious orders
Jesuits · Franciscans — same tradition, neither descended from the other
Any two bodies
All bodies at once
| Question | Acts 29 | ACNA | RC (institutes) | ELCA | GMC | Hillsong Church | PCUSA | PCA | RC (dioceses) | TEC | LCMS | Franciscans | Jesuits | SBC | UMC |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Who owns the building? | The local congregation | Mixed — varies by congregation or state | A regional body | The local congregation | The local congregation | The national body | The congregation, held in trust for the denomination | The local congregation | A corporation sole (the bishop's office) | The congregation, held in trust for the denomination | The local congregation | Someone outside the body — by design | Mixed — varies by congregation or state | The local congregation | The congregation, held in trust for the denomination |
| How does a church get its pastor? | Called by the congregation | Both — call within a supervised process | Appointed | Not established | Appointed | Appointed | Both — call within a supervised process | Both — call within a supervised process | Appointed | Both — call within a supervised process | Called by the congregation | Appointed | Appointed | Called by the congregation | Appointed |
| Who is the pastor's employer? | The local congregation | The local congregation | The national body | Not established | Split — the congregation pays, but does not hire | The national body | The local congregation | The local congregation | Split — the congregation pays, but does not hire | The local congregation | The local congregation | The national body | The national body | The local congregation | Split — the congregation pays, but does not hire |
| What money leaves the congregation? | Contractual or licensed | Assessed by formula | All of it — nothing is held locally | Voluntary, no stated rate | Assessed by formula | All of it — nothing is held locally | Assessed by formula | Voluntary, no stated rate | Assessed by formula | Assessed by formula | Voluntary, no stated rate | All of it — nothing is held locally | All of it — nothing is held locally | Voluntary, at a stated percentage | Assessed by formula |
| Who oversees the congregation? | A board of directors | A bishop, elected for fixed terms | The institute's own superiors | A bishop, elected for fixed terms | A bishop, elected for fixed terms | A board of directors | A council of elders, not a person | A council of elders, not a person | A bishop, appointed from outside the local body | A bishop, holding office for life | Nothing above the congregation | The institute's own superiors | The institute's own superiors | Nothing above the congregation | A bishop, holding office for life |
| Who owns the church's name? | The denomination, licensed to the congregation | Not established | Not established | Not established | The denomination, licensed to the congregation | The denomination — the congregation is a unit of it | Not established | Not established | The denomination — the congregation is a unit of it | Not established | Not established | Not established | Not established | No one controls it | The denomination, licensed to the congregation |
| How does a congregation leave? | The congregation may simply vote to go | The congregation may simply vote to go | The governing documents provide no path | Through a defined process, with conditions | Through a defined process, with conditions | The governing documents provide no path | Disputed in practice | The congregation may simply vote to go | The governing documents provide no path | Disputed in practice | Not established | The governing documents provide no path | The governing documents provide no path | The congregation may simply vote to go | The governing documents provide no path |
| Coverage | Partial — some structures are not publicly documented | Built from primary governing documents | Partial — some structures are not publicly documented | Partial — some structures are not publicly documented | Built from primary governing documents | Partial — some structures are not publicly documented | Partial — some structures are not publicly documented | Partial — some structures are not publicly documented | Partial — some structures are not publicly documented | Built from primary governing documents | Built from primary governing documents | Built from primary governing documents | Built from primary governing documents | Built from primary governing documents | Built from primary governing documents |