Compare

The table below sets every body against every question. For two bodies at a time, a pair page puts each one's own sourced account beneath the answer — which is where the real distance shows.

Pairs worth reading together

Any two bodies can be compared, and there is a page for every combination. These are the ones that carry an argument: three where one body was formed by congregations leaving the other, and three where a shared tradition turns out to settle less than a reader would expect.

Any two bodies

All bodies at once

Question Acts 29 ACNA RC (institutes) ELCA GMC Hillsong Church PCUSA PCA RC (dioceses) TEC LCMS Franciscans Jesuits SBC UMC
Who owns the building? The local congregationMixed — varies by congregation or stateA regional bodyThe local congregationThe local congregationThe national bodyThe congregation, held in trust for the denominationThe local congregationA corporation sole (the bishop's office)The congregation, held in trust for the denominationThe local congregationSomeone outside the body — by designMixed — varies by congregation or stateThe local congregationThe congregation, held in trust for the denomination
How does a church get its pastor? Called by the congregationBoth — call within a supervised processAppointedNot establishedAppointedAppointedBoth — call within a supervised processBoth — call within a supervised processAppointedBoth — call within a supervised processCalled by the congregationAppointedAppointedCalled by the congregationAppointed
Who is the pastor's employer? The local congregationThe local congregationThe national bodyNot establishedSplit — the congregation pays, but does not hireThe national bodyThe local congregationThe local congregationSplit — the congregation pays, but does not hireThe local congregationThe local congregationThe national bodyThe national bodyThe local congregationSplit — the congregation pays, but does not hire
What money leaves the congregation? Contractual or licensedAssessed by formulaAll of it — nothing is held locallyVoluntary, no stated rateAssessed by formulaAll of it — nothing is held locallyAssessed by formulaVoluntary, no stated rateAssessed by formulaAssessed by formulaVoluntary, no stated rateAll of it — nothing is held locallyAll of it — nothing is held locallyVoluntary, at a stated percentageAssessed by formula
Who oversees the congregation? A board of directorsA bishop, elected for fixed termsThe institute's own superiorsA bishop, elected for fixed termsA bishop, elected for fixed termsA board of directorsA council of elders, not a personA council of elders, not a personA bishop, appointed from outside the local bodyA bishop, holding office for lifeNothing above the congregationThe institute's own superiorsThe institute's own superiorsNothing above the congregationA bishop, holding office for life
Who owns the church's name? The denomination, licensed to the congregationNot establishedNot establishedNot establishedThe denomination, licensed to the congregationThe denomination — the congregation is a unit of itNot establishedNot establishedThe denomination — the congregation is a unit of itNot establishedNot establishedNot establishedNot establishedNo one controls itThe denomination, licensed to the congregation
How does a congregation leave? The congregation may simply vote to goThe congregation may simply vote to goThe governing documents provide no pathThrough a defined process, with conditionsThrough a defined process, with conditionsThe governing documents provide no pathDisputed in practiceThe congregation may simply vote to goThe governing documents provide no pathDisputed in practiceNot establishedThe governing documents provide no pathThe governing documents provide no pathThe congregation may simply vote to goThe governing documents provide no path
Coverage Partial — some structures are not publicly documentedBuilt from primary governing documentsPartial — some structures are not publicly documentedPartial — some structures are not publicly documentedBuilt from primary governing documentsPartial — some structures are not publicly documentedPartial — some structures are not publicly documentedPartial — some structures are not publicly documentedPartial — some structures are not publicly documentedBuilt from primary governing documentsBuilt from primary governing documentsBuilt from primary governing documentsBuilt from primary governing documentsBuilt from primary governing documentsBuilt from primary governing documents